The Songs That Stay: A reflection on music, pain, and the quiet work of healing

Some songs find you. You do not go looking for them. They arrive at the right moment and somehow stay. You hear them in the car late at night, walking into work, or in the middle of an ordinary day when something in you suddenly feels understood. Sometimes they carry words you could not yet say for yourself.

In my office, certain songs seem to return again and again. Different people bring them in. Different ages, different histories, different kinds of pain. And yet, somehow, they often speak to the very same places inside us.

Three songs in particular have stayed with me.

The first is I’m Not Okay by Jelly Roll. Even the title says something important. Not I’ll be okay. Not I was struggling but now I’m healed. Just: I’m not okay. Present tense. Honest. No performance. No pretending.

There is a line in the song: “So if I say I’m fine, just know I learned to hide it well.” That line has stayed with me. So many people function beautifully on the outside while privately unraveling underneath. They go to work. They smile. They answer texts. They keep commitments. And all the while, they are carrying more than anyone knows.

What moves me about the song is that it does not rush toward resolution. It does not try to clean pain up too quickly. It simply tells the truth. Sometimes truth is the first form of healing.

The second is לצאת מדיכאון by Yigal Oshri and Ofir Cohen.

The title itself feels brave. It names something many people would rather avoid naming. Depression. It does not hide behind vague language or metaphor. And yet the song is not harsh. It is tender. It reaches toward hope without forcing it. There is a line that says, “It’s always darkest before the sunrise.” We have heard versions of that phrase before, but sometimes hearing it in the right voice, at the right time, makes all the difference.

The third is One More Light by Linkin Park. A song about grief, worth, and the quiet ache of wondering whether one life, one struggle, one loss truly matters. It answers its own question with heartbreaking simplicity.

Over time, these songs became connected in my mind with some of the people who brought them into the room.

One young man carried a secret so heavy it had begun to feel physical. His sexuality. His fear of how his parents might respond. The painful question of whether to stay, hide, or leave. He listened to I’m Not Okay on repeat because it was the first thing he had heard that did not demand that he be fine. It gave him permission to be exactly where he was. Sometimes healing begins the moment someone stops pretending.

Another was a teenager whose sister battled cancer for two years and then died. Lo aleinu. After that, he became quiet. He shut everyone out — not because he did not love them, but because grief can become so overwhelming that even closeness feels dangerous. He found Latzet MiDikaon and told me it felt like a door. Not one he was ready to walk through yet. But one he could finally see.

There is another line in the song: “Even in the dark hours of the night, there will always be a small star that will light for you.” Sometimes that is all a grieving person needs at first — not daylight, just one small star.

Then there was the young man whose mother had always been strong, steady, dependable — until a neurological illness changed everything with shocking speed. He was grieving someone who was still alive. There is no clean language for that kind of loss. I’m Not Okay met him when he needed to stop pretending. Latzet MiDikaon met him when he was finally able to imagine that one day he might feel like himself again.

Elsewhere sat a father carrying the particular heartbreak known to parents of medically fragile children — the waiting, the uncertainty, the endless hope mixed with dread. No clear diagnosis. No roadmap. No ability to simply fix what hurts. He told me there was a line in I’m Not Okay that stayed with him: “I know I can’t be the only one holding on for dear life.” For the first time in months, he felt less alone.

But another song reached a different place in him. Beneath all the exhaustion was the fierce, frightened love every parent knows. The kind that hears the question, “Who cares if one more light goes out?” and answers immediately: “Well I do.”

Sometimes love sounds exactly like that.

And somewhere in those same years was a young man whose engagement had broken apart after he poured every ounce of himself into trying to save it. His kallah was beautiful, loving in many ways, and deeply dysregulated. He kept believing that if he just loved harder, explained better, sacrificed more, something would settle. Instead, trust eroded. He was blamed, confused, and slowly began doubting his own reality. Some sessions began with the honesty of I’m not okay.Others ended with him repeating another line softly: “But it’s all gonna be alright.” At first he said it like a question. Eventually, more like a possibility.

What do these songs know that we sometimes forget?

They know healing is rarely linear. They know people can be hurting deeply and still keep showing up. They know naming pain is not weakness. Saying I’m not okay is not failure. Sometimes it is the first honest step toward becoming okay again.

There is a line in Latzet MiDikaon that says, “You get up and fall, but in your own way.” That may be one of the most honest descriptions of healing I know. We rise imperfectly. We stumble personally. We move forward unevenly. But we move.

These songs do not promise easy mornings or quick transformations. They do not deny how dark things can become. What they offer is something steadier: witness. Someone else has felt this. Someone else has survived this moment. Someone else turned pain into melody and sent it into the world, where it found you.

That is also what therapy tries to do on its best days. To bear witness. To stay present. To not rush pain. To not look away. To sit with the young man terrified to be known, the boy silenced by grief, the son losing his mother in slow motion, the parent watching a child suffer, the groom whose heart was shattered — and to hold hope for them until they can hold some of it themselves.

Music often gets there before words do. Sometimes it also helps people honor what they have lost.

I am grateful these songs exist. I am grateful people trusted me enough to bring them into the room. And I am grateful, always, for those who entrusted me with both their pain and the music that carried it.

Some songs find you. You do not go looking for them. They seem to arrive when something in you is ready to hear them.

And when someone cannot yet believe in better days, sometimes they borrow a line from a song until they can believe it themselves: “Good days will come, I promise” — “עוד יבואו ימים טובים אני מבטיח” (Latzet MiDikaon).

Permission was granted to use these scenarios.

Warmly,

Dr. Neal

‍ ‍